10edo: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Reference
added intro
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{problematic}}
'''10edo''', or 10 equal divisions of the octave (sometimes called '''10-TET''' or '''10-tone equal temperament'''), is the equal tuning featuring steps of (1200/10) = 120 cents, 10 of which stack to the perfect octave [[2/1]].
'''10edo''', or 10 equal divisions of the octave (sometimes called '''10-TET''' or '''10-tone equal temperament'''), is the equal tuning featuring steps of (1200/10) = 120 cents, 10 of which stack to the perfect octave [[2/1]].


As the double of [[5edo]], 10edo has its sharp [[perfect fifth|fifth]] of 720{{c}}, and approximates [[7/4]] well by 960{{c}}. It divides this fifth in two so that it possesses a [[neutral third]] of 360{{c}} that is extremely close to [[16/13]]. Both [[6/5]] and [[5/4]] are mapped to this neutral third, and in this fashion 10edo provides a very primitive basis for the [[7-limit]].
As the double of [[5edo]], 10edo has its sharp [[perfect fifth|fifth]] of 720{{c}}, and approximates [[7/4]] well by 960{{c}}. It divides this fifth in two so that it possesses a [[neutral third]] of 360{{c}} that is extremely close to [[16/13]]. Both [[6/5]] and [[5/4]] are mapped to this neutral third, and in this fashion 10edo provides a primitive structural basis for the [[7-limit]].
 
10edo occupies a position intermediate between the "[[albitonic]]" systems such as [[7edo]], and "chromatic" systems such as [[12edo]]. While scales such as [[3L 4s]] can be used as a structural backbone when working within 10edo, the [[10-form]] itself can serve as a basic form in tuning systems, more analogous to the [[7-form]].
 
== Theory ==
=== Chords ===
10edo is arguably the first edo to have three triads consisting of two [[third]]s to make a fifth. However, aside from the neutral triad, the other two use 5edo intervals, which are equivalent to major seconds and perfect fourths. Treating these intervals as thirds relies on the fact that stacking two sharp fifths minus an octave makes an inframinor third, thus fundamentally using oneirotonic logic.
 
Tendo: 0-4-6-(10)
 
Neutral: 0-3-6-(9)
 
Arto: 0-2-6-(8)
 
See also: [[Oneirotonic#Chords_of_oneirotonic]]
 
=== Scales ===
Example mosh (3L 4s): 0-1-3-4-6-7-9-10


Mosh is the most characteristic scale in 10edo.
10edo occupies a position intermediate between the "[[albitonic]]" systems such as [[7edo]], and "chromatic" systems such as [[12edo]]. While scales such as [[3L 4s]] can be used as a structural backbone when working within 10edo, the [[10-form]] itself can serve as a basic form in tuning systems, more analogous to the [[7-form]]. In particular, 10edo's division of the perfect fifth into six and the [[perfect fourth]] into four allows it to represent a trivial tuning of temperaments such as [[Miracle]] and [[Negri]].


Example subaric (2L 6s): 0-1-2-4-5-6-7-9-10
== General theory ==
=== JI approximation ===
10edo contains unambiguous representations of the harmonics within the 2.3.5.7.13.17 subgroup, while primes 11 and 19 fall nearly halfway between its steps. {{adv|10edo's representation of this group equalizes an arithmetic division of the perfect fifth into six parts: 12:13:14:15:16:17:18, which contains as subsets 6:7:8:9 (the 2.3.7 subgroup, being its inheritance from 5edo) and 4:5:6.}}


In subaric the "simic pentachord" 0-1-2-4-6 approximates the diatonic minor pentachord in the only way 10edo is able to. A potential temperament for this interpretation of soft subaric is 10 & 2[-7] 2.3.7.17; in other words, Trienstonian plus a 17/12 half-octave.
While 10edo has [[consistent]] representations of every interval within the no-11s 17-[[odd-limit]] save [[10/9]] and its complement, it still makes extreme temperings (such as the vanishing of [[25/24]]) that put many of these intervals out of recognition. The primary subgroup in which 10edo is of notable accuracy is 2.7.13.15; in particular, the intervals 16/13 and [[15/14]] are approximated within 0.6{{c}}.
{{Harmonics in ED|10|19|prime}}


=== Detempers ===
=== Edostep interpretations ===
Due to its small size and unique melodic character, it is very easy to detemper 10edo. Example tunings are shown in parenthesis.
One step of 10edo can be interpreted in the 2.3.5.7.13.17 subgroup as:
 
* [[21/20]] (the interval between 8/7 and 6/5)
Full octave, neutral third generator
* [[18/17]] (the interval between 17/16 and 9/8)
* Sharp (13\43), 3L7s
* [[17/16]] (the octave-reduced 17th harmonic)
** Mainly oneirotonic fifth
* [[16/15]] (the interval between 5/4 and 4/3)
** Good approximation of 19:22:25:27:29
* 15/14 (the interval between 7/6 and 5/4)
** Similar to Submajor/Interpental temperament
* [[14/13]] (the interval between 8/7 and 16/13)
* Flat (11\37), 7L3s
* [[13/12]] (the interval between 16/13 and 4/3)
** Mainly diatonic fifth
* 10/9 (the interval between 6/5 and 4/3).
** General 13-limit, especially 2.7.13
Half octave, fifth generator
* Flat (3\32)
** Mainly diatonic fifth
** Oceanfront temperament with added 17/14
* Sharp (4\38)
** Mainly oneirotonic fifth
** Soft subaric


==== The 10-form ====
=== Intervals and notation ===
Intervals in systems approximating 10edo may be conceptualized using the [[10-form]]. This is arguably a more intuitive way of conceptualizing intervals in the 7-limit than the 7-form is.
10edo collapses the diatonic scale into 5edo; in that way, B and C are the same note, and so are E and F. Though, to notate the other five notes of 10edo, we could simply redefine "sharps" and "flats" to correspond to steps of 10edo, we elect to use the symbols "up" and "down" for this purpose.  


The 10-form's key feature is the presence of the tritone as its own interval category separate from fourths and fifths, and the moving of 9/7 and 7/6 away from the category representing thirds. This in effect gives the simplest 7-limit intervals their own pair of categories separate from the simplest 5-limit intervals, much as upgrading from the 5-form to the 7-form gives the simplest 5-limit intervals their own pair of categories.
Another notation scheme uses 10edo's native heptatonic scale, which is mosh (3L 4s), generated by the neutral third. We can assign the names 1234567 to the notes following the 1-2-1-2-1-2-1 step pattern of the mosh scale (which resembles 12edo major diatonic with two of its intervals shortened). Sharps and flats are then one step of 10edo following the conventional definition of the larger step minus the smaller.


A table of 10-form interval regions follows; the boundaries are rough and depend heavily on the tuning system and compositional theory in question.
JI approximations (within the 17-odd-limit) of steps in 10edo, as well as the aforementioned ways of notating 10edo, are detailed in the table below. Intervals within 5 cents are in [brackets], and odd harmonics are bolded.
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|+
|+
!Step
! rowspan="2" | Edostep !! rowspan="2" | Cents !! rowspan="2" | 2.3.5.7.13.17 <br> JI approximation !! colspan="2" | Notation !! rowspan="2" | 10-form <br> interval category
!10edo
|-
!Region
! rowspan="1" | Pentatonic !! rowspan="1" | Mosh
!Names (Tellurian)
!Names (Diatonic)
!Names (Hybrid)
!Solfege (Vector)
!Notable just intervals
|-
|-
|0
|0
|0
|0
|0
|unison
|unison
|unison
|do
|1/1
|1/1
|B, C
|1
|Unison
|-
|-
|1
|1
|120
|120
|50-200
|'''17/16''', 16/15, [15/14], 14/13, 13/12
|grade
|^B, ^C, vD
|second
|2
|second
|Second
|re
|16/15, 10/9
|-
|-
|2
|2
|240
|240
|200-290
|'''9/8''', 8/7, 7/6
|unilatus
|D
|semifourth
|2#, 3b
|unilatus
|Unilatus
|na
|8/7, 7/6
|-
|-
|3
|3
|360
|360
|300-410
|6/5, [16/13], '''5/4'''
|semitres
|^D, vE, vF
|third
|3
|third
|Third
|mi
|6/5, 5/4
|-
|-
|4
|4
|480
|480
|410-540
|9/7, 13/10, 4/3
|bilatus
|E, F
|fourth
|4
|fourth
|Fourth
|fa
|9/7, 4/3
|-
|-
|5
|5
|600
|600
|540-660
|7/5, [17/12], 10/7
|median
|^E, ^F, vG
|tritone
|4#, 5b
|median
|Median
|zi
|7/5, 10/7, 11/8, 16/11
|-
|-
|6
|6
|720
|720
|660-790
|'''3/2''', 20/13, 14/9
|trilatus
|G
|fifth
|5
|fifth
|Fifth
|so
|3/2, 14/9
|-
|-
|7
|7
|840
|840
|790-900
|8/5, ['''13/8'''], 5/3
|semisept
|^G, vA
|sixth
|6
|sixth
|Sixth
|la
|5/3, 8/5
|-
|-
|8
|8
|960
|960
|910-1000
|12/7, '''7/4''', 16/9
|antilatus
|A
|semitwelfth
|6#, 7b
|antilatus
|Antilatus
|be
|7/4, 12/7
|-
|-
|9
|9
|1080
|1080
|1000-1150
|24/13, 13/7, [28/15], '''15/8''', 32/17
|degrade
|^A, vB, vC
|seventh
|7
|seventh
|Seventh
|ti
|15/8, 9/5
|-
|-
|10
|10
|1200
|1200
|1200
|duplance
|octave
|octave
|do
|2/1
|2/1
|B, C
|1
|Octave
|}
|}


The following is a table of 10-note MOSes, the edos they may be found in, and the implied temperaments. All MOSes with an even number of large and small steps were assigned to jubilismic temperaments.
== Compositional theory ==
{| class="wikitable"
=== Chords ===
|+
10edo is arguably the first edo to have three triads consisting of two [[third]]s to make a fifth. However, aside from the neutral triad, the other two use 5edo intervals, which are equivalent to major seconds and perfect fourths. Treating these intervals as thirds relies on the fact that stacking two sharp fifths minus an octave makes an inframinor third, thus fundamentally using oneirotonic logic.
!MOS
 
!EDO
Tendo: 0-4-6-(10)
!Temperament
 
!
Neutral: 0-3-6-(9)
|-
 
|9L 1s
Arto: 0-2-6-(8)
|29
 
|Negri
See also: [[Oneirotonic#Chords of oneirotonic]]
|
 
|-
=== Scales ===
|8L 2s
Example mosh (3L 4s): 0-1-3-4-6-7-9-10
|28
 
|Semibuzzard
Mosh is the most characteristic scale in 10edo.
|
 
|-
Example subaric (2L 6s): 0-1-2-4-5-6-7-9-10
|7L 3s
 
|27
In subaric the "simic pentachord" 0-1-2-4-6 approximates the diatonic minor pentachord in the only way 10edo is able to. A potential temperament for this interpretation of soft subaric is 10 & 2[-7] 2.3.7.17; in other words, Trienstonian plus a 17/12 half-octave.
|Rastmic ''(TODO: find 2.3.5.7 interpretation)''
 
|
=== Detempers ===
|-
Due to its small size and unique melodic character, it is very easy to detemper 10edo. Example tunings are shown in parenthesis.
|6L 4s
 
|26
Full octave, neutral third generator
|Lemba
* Sharp (13\43), 3L7s
|
** Mainly oneirotonic fifth
|-
** Good approximation of 19:22:25:27:29
|5L 5s
** Similar to Submajor/Interpental temperament
|25
* Flat (11\37), 7L3s
|Blackwood
** Mainly diatonic fifth
|
** General 13-limit, especially 2.7.13
|-
 
|4L 6s
Half octave, fifth generator
|24
* Flat (3\32)
|''(TODO: find representative temperament)''
** Mainly diatonic fifth
|
** Oceanfront temperament with added 17/14
|-
* Sharp (4\38)
|3L 7s
** Mainly oneirotonic fifth
|23
** Soft subaric
|Magic
 
|
==== The 10-form ====
|-
''Main article: [[10-form]]''
|2L 8s
 
|22
Intervals in systems approximating 10edo may be conceptualized using the [[10-form]]. This is arguably a more intuitive way of conceptualizing intervals in the 7-limit than the 7-form is.
|Pajara
 
|
The 10-form's key features are the presence of the tritone as its own interval category separate from fourths and fifths, and the moving of 9/7 and 7/6 away from the category representing thirds, into the categories corresponding to fourths and major seconds respectively. The interval classes of "second" and "seventh" are split up into correspondents to "minor" and "major". This in effect gives the simplest 7-limit intervals their own pair of categories separate from the simplest 5-limit intervals, much as upgrading from the 5-form to the 7-form gives the simplest 5-limit intervals their own pair of categories.
|-
|1L 9s
|21
|Miracle
|
|}


{{Cat|Edos}}
{{Cat|Edos}}{{Navbox EDO}}

Latest revision as of 21:00, 26 February 2026

10edo, or 10 equal divisions of the octave (sometimes called 10-TET or 10-tone equal temperament), is the equal tuning featuring steps of (1200/10) = 120 cents, 10 of which stack to the perfect octave 2/1.

As the double of 5edo, 10edo has its sharp fifth of 720¢, and approximates 7/4 well by 960¢. It divides this fifth in two so that it possesses a neutral third of 360¢ that is extremely close to 16/13. Both 6/5 and 5/4 are mapped to this neutral third, and in this fashion 10edo provides a primitive structural basis for the 7-limit.

10edo occupies a position intermediate between the "albitonic" systems such as 7edo, and "chromatic" systems such as 12edo. While scales such as 3L 4s can be used as a structural backbone when working within 10edo, the 10-form itself can serve as a basic form in tuning systems, more analogous to the 7-form. In particular, 10edo's division of the perfect fifth into six and the perfect fourth into four allows it to represent a trivial tuning of temperaments such as Miracle and Negri.

General theory

JI approximation

10edo contains unambiguous representations of the harmonics within the 2.3.5.7.13.17 subgroup, while primes 11 and 19 fall nearly halfway between its steps. 10edo's representation of this group equalizes an arithmetic division of the perfect fifth into six parts: 12:13:14:15:16:17:18, which contains as subsets 6:7:8:9 (the 2.3.7 subgroup, being its inheritance from 5edo) and 4:5:6.

While 10edo has consistent representations of every interval within the no-11s 17-odd-limit save 10/9 and its complement, it still makes extreme temperings (such as the vanishing of 25/24) that put many of these intervals out of recognition. The primary subgroup in which 10edo is of notable accuracy is 2.7.13.15; in particular, the intervals 16/13 and 15/14 are approximated within 0.6¢.

Approximation of prime harmonics in 10edo
Harmonic 2 3 5 7 11 13 17 19
Error Absolute (¢) 0.0 +18.0 -26.3 -8.8 +48.7 -0.5 +15.0 -57.5
Relative (%) 0.0 +15.0 -21.9 -7.4 +40.6 -0.4 +12.5 -47.9
Steps

(reduced)

10

(0)

16

(6)

23

(3)

28

(8)

35

(5)

37

(7)

41

(1)

42

(2)

Edostep interpretations

One step of 10edo can be interpreted in the 2.3.5.7.13.17 subgroup as:

  • 21/20 (the interval between 8/7 and 6/5)
  • 18/17 (the interval between 17/16 and 9/8)
  • 17/16 (the octave-reduced 17th harmonic)
  • 16/15 (the interval between 5/4 and 4/3)
  • 15/14 (the interval between 7/6 and 5/4)
  • 14/13 (the interval between 8/7 and 16/13)
  • 13/12 (the interval between 16/13 and 4/3)
  • 10/9 (the interval between 6/5 and 4/3).

Intervals and notation

10edo collapses the diatonic scale into 5edo; in that way, B and C are the same note, and so are E and F. Though, to notate the other five notes of 10edo, we could simply redefine "sharps" and "flats" to correspond to steps of 10edo, we elect to use the symbols "up" and "down" for this purpose.

Another notation scheme uses 10edo's native heptatonic scale, which is mosh (3L 4s), generated by the neutral third. We can assign the names 1234567 to the notes following the 1-2-1-2-1-2-1 step pattern of the mosh scale (which resembles 12edo major diatonic with two of its intervals shortened). Sharps and flats are then one step of 10edo following the conventional definition of the larger step minus the smaller.

JI approximations (within the 17-odd-limit) of steps in 10edo, as well as the aforementioned ways of notating 10edo, are detailed in the table below. Intervals within 5 cents are in [brackets], and odd harmonics are bolded.

Edostep Cents 2.3.5.7.13.17
JI approximation
Notation 10-form
interval category
Pentatonic Mosh
0 0 1/1 B, C 1 Unison
1 120 17/16, 16/15, [15/14], 14/13, 13/12 ^B, ^C, vD 2 Second
2 240 9/8, 8/7, 7/6 D 2#, 3b Unilatus
3 360 6/5, [16/13], 5/4 ^D, vE, vF 3 Third
4 480 9/7, 13/10, 4/3 E, F 4 Fourth
5 600 7/5, [17/12], 10/7 ^E, ^F, vG 4#, 5b Median
6 720 3/2, 20/13, 14/9 G 5 Fifth
7 840 8/5, [13/8], 5/3 ^G, vA 6 Sixth
8 960 12/7, 7/4, 16/9 A 6#, 7b Antilatus
9 1080 24/13, 13/7, [28/15], 15/8, 32/17 ^A, vB, vC 7 Seventh
10 1200 2/1 B, C 1 Octave

Compositional theory

Chords

10edo is arguably the first edo to have three triads consisting of two thirds to make a fifth. However, aside from the neutral triad, the other two use 5edo intervals, which are equivalent to major seconds and perfect fourths. Treating these intervals as thirds relies on the fact that stacking two sharp fifths minus an octave makes an inframinor third, thus fundamentally using oneirotonic logic.

Tendo: 0-4-6-(10)

Neutral: 0-3-6-(9)

Arto: 0-2-6-(8)

See also: Oneirotonic#Chords of oneirotonic

Scales

Example mosh (3L 4s): 0-1-3-4-6-7-9-10

Mosh is the most characteristic scale in 10edo.

Example subaric (2L 6s): 0-1-2-4-5-6-7-9-10

In subaric the "simic pentachord" 0-1-2-4-6 approximates the diatonic minor pentachord in the only way 10edo is able to. A potential temperament for this interpretation of soft subaric is 10 & 2[-7] 2.3.7.17; in other words, Trienstonian plus a 17/12 half-octave.

Detempers

Due to its small size and unique melodic character, it is very easy to detemper 10edo. Example tunings are shown in parenthesis.

Full octave, neutral third generator

  • Sharp (13\43), 3L7s
    • Mainly oneirotonic fifth
    • Good approximation of 19:22:25:27:29
    • Similar to Submajor/Interpental temperament
  • Flat (11\37), 7L3s
    • Mainly diatonic fifth
    • General 13-limit, especially 2.7.13

Half octave, fifth generator

  • Flat (3\32)
    • Mainly diatonic fifth
    • Oceanfront temperament with added 17/14
  • Sharp (4\38)
    • Mainly oneirotonic fifth
    • Soft subaric

The 10-form

Main article: 10-form

Intervals in systems approximating 10edo may be conceptualized using the 10-form. This is arguably a more intuitive way of conceptualizing intervals in the 7-limit than the 7-form is.

The 10-form's key features are the presence of the tritone as its own interval category separate from fourths and fifths, and the moving of 9/7 and 7/6 away from the category representing thirds, into the categories corresponding to fourths and major seconds respectively. The interval classes of "second" and "seventh" are split up into correspondents to "minor" and "major". This in effect gives the simplest 7-limit intervals their own pair of categories separate from the simplest 5-limit intervals, much as upgrading from the 5-form to the 7-form gives the simplest 5-limit intervals their own pair of categories.

ViewTalkEditEqual temperaments
EDOs
Macrotonal 57891011
12-23 121314151617181920212223
24-35 242526272931323435
36-47 36373940414344454647
48-59 4850515354565758
60-71 60636465676870
72-83 72778081
84-95 848789909394
Large EDOs 99104111118130140152159171217224239270306311612665
Nonoctave equal temperaments
Tritave 4913172639
Fifth 891120
Other