13edo: Difference between revisions
Please do not rename the octave. |
|||
| Line 251: | Line 251: | ||
For each of these chords, we can associate functions with them. The simplest of these relationships is between | For each of these chords, we can associate functions with them. The simplest of these relationships is between | ||
the root major chord and the major chord on the perfect fourth. | the root major chord and the major chord on the perfect fourth. | ||
By adding | By adding octaves on certain notes, we can recreate the familiar dominant cadence | ||
from diatonic, only now on the fourth degree rather than the fifth. The most simple of these progressions would | from diatonic, only now on the fourth degree rather than the fifth. The most simple of these progressions would | ||
look something like this: | look something like this: | ||
| Line 262: | Line 262: | ||
0-2-4-7-17 | 0-2-4-7-17 | ||
In this cadence, the fifth on L is so narrow that it creates a leading tone relative to the root, and by playing the | In this cadence, the fifth on L is so narrow that it creates a leading tone relative to the root, and by playing the | ||
octaves above L, you can create a narrow tritone that wants to resolve inwards to the major chord on the root. | |||
The presence of the | The presence of the octaves above the major third helps drive this resolution, but can be omitted. | ||
Another neat effect is that given the dominant is now on the IV, then the ii minor chord would be exactly | Another neat effect is that given the dominant is now on the IV, then the ii minor chord would be exactly | ||
halfway to the dominant, making it the mediant. It also has a much nicer minor chord on it compared to the iii | halfway to the dominant, making it the mediant. It also has a much nicer minor chord on it compared to the iii | ||
| Line 271: | Line 271: | ||
Celephaïsian, the minor vii). The mediant can also function as a secondary dominant for resolutions to the | Celephaïsian, the minor vii). The mediant can also function as a secondary dominant for resolutions to the | ||
relative minor; the highest note in the ii minor chord is one semitone below the minor third of the vii minor | relative minor; the highest note in the ii minor chord is one semitone below the minor third of the vii minor | ||
chord. By playing the | chord. By playing the octave above certain notes, resolving between the two modes is pretty simple. | ||
Q-J-K-M-Q | Q-J-K-M-Q | ||
`J-`L-`O-`P-P | `J-`L-`O-`P-P | ||
| Line 279: | Line 279: | ||
`2-`5-`10-`12-12 | `2-`5-`10-`12-12 | ||
`10-0-5-7-13 | `10-0-5-7-13 | ||
<`> notates playing | <`> notates playing an octave lower than the root. | ||
The ii (J minor) and vii (O minor) would probably sound the smoothest when played in a lower register than the | The ii (J minor) and vii (O minor) would probably sound the smoothest when played in a lower register than the | ||
tonic (Q major) as notated, but if you want to move upwards from the root it still works. | tonic (Q major) as notated, but if you want to move upwards from the root it still works. | ||
| Line 296: | Line 296: | ||
effect, while the simplified major and minor still have a pseudo-JI effect, though a bit weaker than the tetrads³. | effect, while the simplified major and minor still have a pseudo-JI effect, though a bit weaker than the tetrads³. | ||
The vi+ (augmented vi, N-P-L-M / 9-12-18-20) chord also has some neat features, as it sort of functions as an | The vi+ (augmented vi, N-P-L-M / 9-12-18-20) chord also has some neat features, as it sort of functions as an | ||
inversion of the dominant IV chord. It also doesn't need any extensions with | inversion of the dominant IV chord. It also doesn't need any extensions with octaves to work super well unlike | ||
the dominant chord, so it could be seen as a more tense version of dominant. | the dominant chord, so it could be seen as a more tense version of dominant. | ||
Since it also drives the resolution up by a minor third, the same tetrad on the iii+ (augmented iii) could be used | Since it also drives the resolution up by a minor third, the same tetrad on the iii+ (augmented iii) could be used | ||
| Line 307: | Line 307: | ||
either of these will be similarly strong, that is to say, not very strong. In this case it could also be seen as a | either of these will be similarly strong, that is to say, not very strong. In this case it could also be seen as a | ||
secondary mediant which is not the relative minor, about halfway between the I chord and the IX chord a | secondary mediant which is not the relative minor, about halfway between the I chord and the IX chord a | ||
octave above it, and either of these resolutions would probably sound fine in most contexts. This gives it a role | |||
completely unlike any of the functions in traditional diatonic, and it seems obvious this would happen since | completely unlike any of the functions in traditional diatonic, and it seems obvious this would happen since | ||
there's now eight notes instead of seven. It also works pretty well as a setup for the augmented vi, so in a | there's now eight notes instead of seven. It also works pretty well as a setup for the augmented vi, so in a | ||
| Line 318: | Line 318: | ||
With Ilarnekian being the second major mode (after Dylathian), we'd get the same I chord, Q major. One of the | With Ilarnekian being the second major mode (after Dylathian), we'd get the same I chord, Q major. One of the | ||
most immediate effects we'd see, however, is that the dominant IV is now a minor iv. It still can function as a | most immediate effects we'd see, however, is that the dominant IV is now a minor iv. It still can function as a | ||
dominant, though only with the added | dominant, though only with the added octave above the 4th, and slightly weaker than the Dylathian dominant | ||
cadence. Another interesting thing is that the iv-I cadence is now simultaneously a minor plagal and a dominant | cadence. Another interesting thing is that the iv-I cadence is now simultaneously a minor plagal and a dominant | ||
cadence, radically different from anything in diatonic. | cadence, radically different from anything in diatonic. | ||
| Line 326: | Line 326: | ||
The v chord is still minor, and still functions as a secondary mediant. | The v chord is still minor, and still functions as a secondary mediant. | ||
It gets interesting again when looking at the major VI chord. | It gets interesting again when looking at the major VI chord. | ||
By playing the VI lower than the tonic and playing the | By playing the VI lower than the tonic and playing the octave above the root of the VI chord, you get an | ||
entirely new approach to a dominant chord. The third of the VI is one semitone below the tonic, and the | entirely new approach to a dominant chord. The third of the VI is one semitone below the tonic, and the | ||
nonave above the root is one semitone above the fifth of the tonic chord. This drives a very strong inward | nonave above the root is one semitone above the fifth of the tonic chord. This drives a very strong inward | ||
| Line 339: | Line 339: | ||
`8-`10-`12-2-8 | `8-`10-`12-2-8 | ||
0-2-4-7 | 0-2-4-7 | ||
With <`> again notating playing | With <`> again notating playing an octave lower than the starting chord. | ||
If I'm not mistaken, I think Inthar's approach to this scale uses this as its main dominant chord and Ilarnekian as | If I'm not mistaken, I think Inthar's approach to this scale uses this as its main dominant chord and Ilarnekian as | ||
it's main major mode, due to this being slightly closer to the diatonic sound. That approach would make the iv a | it's main major mode, due to this being slightly closer to the diatonic sound. That approach would make the iv a | ||
Revision as of 10:48, 19 January 2026
13edo, or 13 equal divisions of the octave, is the equal tuning featuring steps of (1200/13) ~= 92.308 cents, 13 of which stack to the octave 2/1. It does not approximate many small prime harmonics well at all, and the JI approximations it does have do not fit very well in a temperament accessed by a particular scale like oneirotonic (they fit better in a neji), so DR-based interpretations may be preferred among 13edo users.
13edo's greatest melodic strength is its proximity to 12edo, whose most important effect is providing an oneirotonic (5L3s, LLsLLsLs) MOS which is a compressed diatonic. A functional system for 13edo oneirotonic is provided below.
Tuning theory
Intervals
Note: The logic of ground's notation is to preserve the diatonic order of nominals for the stacked oneirotonic subfourth generators, with one additional note: BEADGCFX
| Edostep | Cents | Interval region name | ADIN name (Oneirotonic extension) | Oneirotonic TAMNAMS name | Oneirotonic KISS notation | Ground's notation (on A = 440 Hz) | 26edo subset notation (on A = 440 Hz) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | Unison | Unison | Perfect 0-(oneiro)step (P0oneis) | 1 | A | A |
| 1 | 92.3 | Minor 2nd | Minor second | Minor 1-(oneiro)step (m1oneis) | 1# / 2b | A# / Cb | Ax / Bbb |
| 2 | 184.6 | Major 2nd | Major second | Major 1-(oneiro)step (M1oneis) | 2 | C | B |
| 3 | 276.9 | (Sub)minor 3rd | Minor third | Minor 2-(oneiro)step (m2oneis) | 3 | B | Bx / Cb |
| 4 | 369.2 | (Sub)major 3rd | Major third | Major 2-(oneiro)step (M2oneis) Diminished 3-(oneiro)step (d3oneis) |
3# / 4b | B# / Db | C# |
| 5 | 461.5 | Subfourth | Fourth | Perfect 3-(oneiro)step (P3oneis) | 4 | D | Db |
| 6 | 553.8 | Ultrafourth / Infratritone | Minor tritone | Minor 4-(oneiro)step (m4oneis) | 5b | Fb | D# |
| 7 | 647.2 | Ultratritone / Infrafifth | Major tritone | Major 4-(oneiro)step (M4oneis) | 5 | F | Eb |
| 8 | 738.5 | Superfifth | Fifth | Perfect 5-(oneiro)step (P5oneis) | 6 | E | E# / Fbb |
| 9 | 830.8 | (Super)minor 6th | Minor sixth | Augmented 5-(oneiro)step (A5oneis) Minor 6-(oneiro)step (m6oneis) |
6# / 7b | E# / Gb | F |
| 10 | 923.1 | (Super)major 6th | Major sixth | Major 6-(oneiro)step (M6oneis) | 7 | G | Fx / Gbb |
| 11 | 1015.4 | Minor 7th | Minor seventh | Minor 7-(oneiro)step (m7oneis) | 8b | Xb | G |
| 12 | 1107.7 | Major 7th | Major seventh | Major 7-(oneiro)step (M7oneis) | 8 | X | Gx / Abb |
| 13 | 1200 | Octave | Octave | Perfect 8-(oneiro)step (P8oneis) | 1 | A | A |
Prime harmonic approximations
| Harmonic | 2 | 3 | 5 | 7 | 11 | 13 | 17 | 19 | 23 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Error | Absolute (¢) | 0.0 | +36.5 | -17.1 | -45.7 | +2.5 | -9.8 | -12.6 | -20.6 | +17.9 |
| Relative (%) | 0.0 | +39.5 | -18.5 | -49.6 | +2.7 | -10.6 | -13.7 | -22.3 | +19.4 | |
| Steps
(reduced) |
13
(0) |
21
(8) |
30
(4) |
36
(10) |
45
(6) |
48
(9) |
53
(1) |
55
(3) |
59
(7) | |
Edostep interpretations
13edo's edostep functions in the 2.5.11.13 subgroup as:
- 26/25 (the interval between 5/4 and 13/10)
- 55/52 (the interval between 11/8 and 13/10, and between 5/4 and 13/11)
- 128/121 (the interval between 11/8 and 16/11)
Harmonic series approximations
13edo approximates the following harmonic series chord well (x indicates notes that are harder to approximate):
34:36:38:40:42:x:47:x:52:55:58:61:x:68
Making an over-17 13edo neji thus requires you to choose those three notes:
- The notes resulting in lowest pairwise error in mode 34 are 44, 49, and 64.
- The closest notes in mode 68 are 89, 99, and 129 (which are significantly more complex).
- A less accurate but lower-complexity neji (limited to oneirotonic) is 22:25:26:29:32:34:38:42:44, so one could specifically choose 44, 50, and 64.
Jaimbee and Inthar's functional system for 13edo
The following system has been developed by Jaimbee and Inthar.
13edo's melodically strongest scale is the oneirotonic MOS (preserving the diatonic property of having at least 2 semitones), so it behooves us to find harmonies that work for it. Since there are certain similarities of oneirotonic to diatonic, we can build off of these similarities to assign functions to oneirotonic degrees.
For a DR-forward framework like this, prefer mellow timbres to bright ones to bring out the DR effect.
Basic chords
The most basic chords in this functional harmony system are:
- Major triad 0-4-7\13: A compressed major triad that sounds desaturated and somewhat bittersweet. Somewhat dubiously +1+1. Oneirotonic provides only two of these triads, so alterations are somewhat frequently used to get a major triad. The major triad has the following important tetrad supersets:
- 0-2-4-7\13: Reinforces the quasi-DR effect with an extra tone; approximately +1+1+2.
- 0-4-7-10\13: A compressed dominant tetrad; approximately +1+?+1.
- 0-4-7-12\13
- Minor +1+2 triad 0-3-8\13: A bright and brooding if somewhat hollow-sounding minor triad. Approximately 17:20:26. The important supersets are:
- 0-3-8-10: Approximately +1+2+1.
- 0-3-8-12: Approximately +1+2+2.
- 0-3-8-11: Something like a minor 7th tetrad.
- 0-3-8-15
- 0-3-8-12-15: A concatenation of the minor +1+2 and major +1+1 triads.
- 0-5-9\13: A +1+1 triad and a compressed 2nd inversion major triad. Approximately 13:17:21.
- 0-5-7-9: Approximately +2+1+1.
- 0-5-9-12: A compressed major triad on top of a subfourth.
- 0-5-9-12-15
- 0-5-7-9-12-15-17
- 0-5-7\13: Compressed sus4. Approximately +2+1.
- 0-4-8\13: "Submajor augmented" triad.
- 0-3-6\13: The most diminished-like triad.
Functional patterns
13edo oneiro enjoys two main (rooted) delta-rational sonorities analogous to major and minor triads: 0-(185)-369-646 ("delta-rational major triad" or just "major"/"Maj") and 0-277-738-923 ("delta-rational minor tetrad" or just "minor"/"min"). One of these chords are on the root in the 6 brightest modes of oneirotonic. In the two darkest modes, I think 0-277-738-1015 or 0-738-1015-277 works well. The chord 0-277-738 will be called "minor triad" or "mintri", and 0-277-646-923 will be called "minor diminished" or "mindim".
A progression on the ascending Celephaïsian scale
A progression on the ascending Melodic Mnarian scale
Adding 923 and 1108 to chords works well, and for jazzy extensions one can add 185, 461, and 646 to the upper octave.
A Mnarian loop with an &8 leading tone at the end
Some motherchords of oneiro modes
Functional chords on each degree
Celephaisian
- 0d: minor
- 1d: minor
- 2d: major
- 3d: minor, mindim
- 4d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 5d: major
- 6d: minor
- 7d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
Progressions
kd(maj) means the triad 0 369 646 on kd, kd(min) means the tetrad 0 277 738 923 on kd
Common motions:
- 0d(maj or min) → M1d(min)
- 0d(maj or min) → 4d(min) (when ending on 0d this sounds like diatonic V to I)
- 0d(maj or min) → m6d(min)
- 0d(maj) → 5d(maj), 0d(min) → 5d(maj or min) (when ending on 0d this is a "dominant to tonic" motion)
- 0d(maj) → M3d(maj)
- 2d(min) → m1d(maj) → 0d(maj) (pseudo tritone sub)
Functional harmony
Modes can be grouped by their functional properties.
- Dual-fifth: Illarnekian, Celephaïsian, Ultharian
- Dual-fourth: Mnarian, Kadathian, Hlanithian
- Major pJI chord on root: Dylathian, Illarnekian
- Minor pJI chord on root: Celephaïsian, Ultharian, Mnarian, Kadathian
- Lower leading tone: Dylathian, Illarnekian, Celephaïsian
- "Neoclassical functional modes" (loose grouping): Dylathian, Illarnekian, Celephaïsian, Ultharian
- Upper leading tone: Kadathian, Hlanithian, Sarnathian,
- Minor 6-mosstep: Hlanithian, Sarnathian,
- 0 462 831 delta-rational chord on root: Dylathian, Dylydian, Hlanithian,
- "Dorian-like", i.e. no leading tone, 5d is minor, and 6d is major: Ultharian, Mnarian
- 7d is minor: Kadathian, Hlanithian
We'll call degrees that don't have the major delta-rational or the minor delta-rational chord dissonant degrees (keeping in mind that dissonance is a feature a chord has in a musical language rather than a purely psychoacoustic property).
Dylathian
Ilarnekian
Celephaïsian
Functional chords on each degree:
- 0d: min
- 1d: min
- 2d: Maj
- 3d: min
- 4d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 5d: Maj
- 6d: min
- 7d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
The main resolving degrees (analogues to dominant in diatonic) are 3d and 5d because of their leading tones.
Motherchord: 0d-m2d-P5d-M6d-(M7d)-M1d-P3d-M5d-(M7d)
Progressions:
- 0d(min) 1d(min) 3d(min or mindim) 0d(min)
- 0d(min) 1d(min) 6d(min) 3d(min or mindim) 0d(min)
- 0d(min) 6d(min) 3d(min or mindim) 0d(min)
- 0d(min) 2d(Maj) 3d(min or mindim) 0d(min)
- 0d(min) 4d(min7) 5d(Maj)/3d(min or mindim) 0d(min)
- 0d(min) 6d(min) 5d(Maj) 0d(min)
Secondary modes:
- 3d Ultharian
- 2d Dylathian
- 5d Illarnekian
Ultharian
- 0d: min
- 1d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 2d: Maj
- 3d: min
- 4d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 5d: min
- 6d: min
- 7d: Maj
Ultharian and Mnarian often behave like Dorian because they lack a leading tone. Resolving degrees: 3d(min), 5d(min), 7d(Maj)
Mnarian
- 0d: min
- 1d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 2d: min
- 3d: min
- 4d: Maj
- 5d: min
- 6d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 7d: Maj
Resolving degrees: 3d(min), 5d(min), 7d(Maj)
Kadathian
- 0d: min
- 1d: Maj
- 2d: min
- 3d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 4d: Maj
- 5d: min
- 6d: minor triad, minor 4ms, minor 6ms, minor 7ms
- 7d: min
Resolving degrees: 2d(min)?, 4d(Maj), 5d(min), 7d(min)
Hlanithian and Sarn
Main tonic chord is 0-3-8-11\13 (min7), works well with m6d(maj) and m7d(min7).
