21edo: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Reference
mNo edit summary
Line 12: Line 12:
=== Intervals and notation ===
=== Intervals and notation ===
Since 21edo's best fifth is from 7edo, 21edo is notated with CDEFGAB representing 7edo and up/down representing 1\21. This allows all intervals to have a "minor", "neutral/perfect", and "major" variant.
Since 21edo's best fifth is from 7edo, 21edo is notated with CDEFGAB representing 7edo and up/down representing 1\21. This allows all intervals to have a "minor", "neutral/perfect", and "major" variant.
{| class="wikitable"
|+
! | Edostep !! | Cents !! rowspan="2" | JI approximation !! colspan="3" | Notation (Ups an ddowns) !! rowspan="2" | Interval category <br> (ADIN)
|-
|0
|0
|1/1
|C
|Perfect unison
|-
|1
|57.1
|^C
|
|-
|2
|114.3
|vD
|Minor second
|-
|3
|171.4
|D
|Perfect second
|-
|4
|228.6
|8/7
|^D
|Major second
|-
|5
|285.7
|vE
|Minor third
|-
|6
|342.9
|E
|Perfect/Neutral third
|-
|7
|400
|^E
|Major third
|-
|8
|457.1
|^E
|Minor fourth
|-
|9
|514.3
|F
|Perfect fourth
|-
|10
|571.4
|^F
|Major fourth
|-
|11
|628.6
|vG
|Minor fifth
|-
|12
|685.7
|G
|Perfect fifth
|-
|13
|742.9
|^G
|Major fifth
|-
|14
|800
|vA
|Minor sixth
|-
|15
|857.1
|A
|Neutral sixth
|-
|16
|914.3
|^A
|Major sixth
|-
|17
|971.4
|vB
|Minor seventh
|-
|18
|1028.6
|B
|Perfect seventh
|-
|19
|1085.7
|^B
|Major seventh
|-
|20
|1142.9
|vC
|
|-
|21
|1200
|C
|Octave
|}


=== Prime harmonic approximations ===
=== Prime harmonic approximations ===

Revision as of 15:59, 13 February 2026

21edo is an equal division of the octave into 21 steps of 1200c/21 ~= 57.1c each.

21edo is unusual from a regular temperament perspective due to its mixture of very accurate (e.g. 23/16, 16/15) and very inaccurate (3/2, 6/5, 7/6) approximations. On the one hand, one could say 21edo has a 5 since its 15/8 is accurate due to error cancellation of the sharp 5 with the flat 3. In root-position major triads, though, the 400c major third sounds much less isodifferential than even in 12edo due to the 3/2 being much flatter, and root-position major and minor triads sound somewhat neogothic as a result and also because of the neominor third; the reverse is true of certain triad inversions, since 0-514-914 is close to being +1+1 DR (approximately 23:31:39).

Notable scales:

  • Archylino diatonic (2L3m2s): 3423432 or 4323432
  • Interseptimal diatonic (4L1m2s): 4143414
  • 21edo is the first edo with a diasem scale: 323132313 (RH) or 313231323 (LH). Diasem provides basic 2.3.7 harmony, though 7/6, 28/27, and 9/7 are not accurate at all in 21edo.
  • Slentonic (5L6s, sLsLsLsLsLs), interpreted as Slendric[11], generated by stacking the ~8/7 (4\21)
  • Oneirotonic (5L3s, LLsLLsLs), generated by stacking 8\21

Basic theory

Intervals and notation

Since 21edo's best fifth is from 7edo, 21edo is notated with CDEFGAB representing 7edo and up/down representing 1\21. This allows all intervals to have a "minor", "neutral/perfect", and "major" variant.

Edostep Cents JI approximation Notation (Ups an ddowns) Interval category
(ADIN)
0 0 1/1 C Perfect unison
1 57.1 ^C
2 114.3 vD Minor second
3 171.4 D Perfect second
4 228.6 8/7 ^D Major second
5 285.7 vE Minor third
6 342.9 E Perfect/Neutral third
7 400 ^E Major third
8 457.1 ^E Minor fourth
9 514.3 F Perfect fourth
10 571.4 ^F Major fourth
11 628.6 vG Minor fifth
12 685.7 G Perfect fifth
13 742.9 ^G Major fifth
14 800 vA Minor sixth
15 857.1 A Neutral sixth
16 914.3 ^A Major sixth
17 971.4 vB Minor seventh
18 1028.6 B Perfect seventh
19 1085.7 ^B Major seventh
20 1142.9 vC
21 1200 C Octave

Prime harmonic approximations

Approximation of prime harmonics in 21edo
Harmonic 2 3 5 7 11 13 17 19 23 29
Error Absolute (¢) 0.0 -16.2 +13.7 +2.6 +20.1 +16.6 +9.3 -11.8 +0.3 -1.0
Relative (%) 0.0 -28.4 +24.0 +4.6 +35.2 +29.1 +16.3 -20.6 +0.5 -1.8
Steps

(reduced)

21

(0)

33

(12)

49

(7)

59

(17)

73

(10)

78

(15)

86

(2)

89

(5)

95

(11)

102

(18)

Erac group

As a temperament, 21edo may be described using eracs: 2.x>3.x<5.7.x<11.x<13.23.29. These specific eracs indicate that the primes are about 1/3 of an edostep off, and that 63edo is an accurate system.

Edostep interpretations

21edo's edostep has the following interpretations in the 2.3.5.7.23.29 subgroup:

  • 24/23
  • 30/29
  • 29/28
  • 49/48
  • 50/49
  • 46/45
  • 64/63

Multiples

63edo

63edo provides a good representation of 2.3.5.7.11.13.23.29.31.

  • The 3 is somewhat sharp, thus supporting Parapyth temperament, a rank-3 temperament 32/27 is tuned close to 13/11 and 81/64 is tempered together with 14/11, and where the "spacer" 28/27 is identified with 33/32.
  • The 5 is quite flat, thus supporting Magic temperament where the stack of five 5/4 major thirds becomes one 3/1.